Kemosabe, thanks for your fairness in saying you've "dished it out" as well as received it! Being able to stick with what we agree on, is (IMO) an attitude this world desperately needs! I suppose all the brouhaha comes from trying to figure out what we agree on.
Basically - yes. I can't say I am an atheist, but I can definitely say without a doubt that 'Freedom of Religion is Freedom FROM Religion' I've seen too much evil perpetrated in the name of someone's deity that I tend to believe it all to be BS. Some of the most well-adjusted people I've met are either Wiccan, agnostic, or atheists. Religion != Faith.