WeatherTech or HuskyLiner Mats?

I have the Husky Liners- IIRC the sides are higher on the Husky Liners so it helps keep more junk, snow, water, etc... on the mat vs slopping over onto the carpet.

 

Very satisfied with my Husky liners. 1 year and no problems.

 

Are you comparing Weathertech Floor Liners or Weathertech Floor mats?

If you are comparing "Mats"....I think I'd go with the HuskyLiner Mats.

If you want a good looking floor liner, The Weathertech digital fit floor liners are the most appealing looking option.

 

As a fellow Oregonian, I say why do you feel you need the mats if you already have the liners?

To be honest, I'd probably purchase ONLY mats if I was doing it over. But for most Oregon environments I find the weathertech liners to offer excellent protection. I don't feel I need anything else.

My only criticism of the light gray colored liners is how quickly they show dirt. But as far as protection goes they are great.

 

Ah...well good luck.

I have the weathertech hatchback liner and the digital fit liners for the driver, passenger and back seat.

When clean, they look great, and they protect fantastically....

But they do show the dirt, and trap any water or moisture so well that I find myself cleaning the liners quite often. There is very little covert absorption of any matter. Which I suppose it good if your goal is just keeping the interior clean.

My old OEM all weather rubber mats in my Honda Fit, protected but also hid some of the dirt for at least a period of time. I could get by with NOT cleaning them after a rain storm.

Don't find that to be the reality, unless I just ignore how it looks with the light gray colored Digital Fit Liners.

I'm not unhappy with the liners....but I think I'd go with "mats"---probably the Husky, if I was starting over from scratch.

 

No, what I'm saying is that while I like the custom fit look and protection of the digital fit liners....not made of rubber, they are hard to keep looking clean.

The Husky Mats...and Weathertech Mats both are made of a different material than the digital fit liners.

If I had to do it over again, I think I'd get "custom fit" mats as opposed to the liners.

But actually we are talking about 3 different products here, by two different manufacturers, and from what I've read and heard they are all good products.

 

Can't speak for Husky but I have WeatherTech and they are great, I have the sidewall ones. Good product.

 

From what is shown above: my wife has the floor mats and I have the liners; while the mats are good, the liners are better. Mats will do a good job, liners a better job.

 

..Both Weathertech that is...

 

Weather Tech is BETTER

 

Does anybody know whether the black or the light gray would look better in the Dark Gray interior of my Prius? I read above that the light gray ones show dirt but I'm worried that the black might be odd looking. I just got my car and I want to get mats or liners before the winter sets in.

 

I have the gray husky liners in my dark gray interior and they look just fine. The match the color of the carpeting which is light gray.

 

As an alternative, I purchased ( year and a half ago) the OEM mats and cargo liner and I'm very happy with them

 

I've had the Husky liners, Weathertech rubber mats, and Weathertech digital-fit liners in various vehicles over the years. My opinons from worst to best:

- Weathertech rubber mats are only semi-custom are usualy require trimming of the rear mats to get them to clear seat tracks, etc. Lots of carpet is usually exposed around the edges and winter slop gets on that exposed carpet. I have only bought these mats on a couple vehicles that did not have Weathertech digital liners.

- Husky Liners have an rugged, industrial look and provide good carpet coverage. However, they don't extend very high up the sides and, on some vehicles, melted snow tended to run over the edge of the liner in the corners. I generally prefer Husky liners for rear cargo areas.

- WeatherTech digital liners are my go-to winter liners for all of my vehicles. With my current daily driver Prius and Ridgeline, I leave them in year round. They have high edges and do a great job covering all of the carpet. I regularly recommend these liners.

That said, I use the Toyota rubber liner for the rear cargo area on the Prius as it provides easy access to the lower trunk area.

 

Only thing I dont like about the Husky Liners is that they dont use the factory retention hooks and mine scoot up a couple inches.