1. Attachments are working again! Check out this thread for more details and to report any other bugs.

exhaust wrap

Discussion in 'Gen 2 Prius Fuel Economy' started by Lather, Oct 15, 2005.

  1. Lather

    Lather New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 25, 2005
    27
    0
    0
    Disclaimer: I know that you never get back what you put into the car. And as my wife says, “Playing high score is a sickness.â€

    Regardless, winter is coming. I’m assuming that an hour or two with a block heater is a good thing. But what about an exhaust wrap? It’s not that expensive.
     
  2. altaskier

    altaskier New Member

    Joined:
    May 15, 2004
    157
    1
    0
    Location:
    Long Island, New York
    What is an exhaust wrap? Why would a hot tailpipe help? I suppose a pre-heated catalytic converter would help with reducing emissions the first five minutes you drive the car...
     
  3. c4

    c4 Active Member

    Joined:
    Mar 29, 2005
    607
    51
    0
    As mentioned, the tailpipe really doesn't matter, but if you wrapped from exhaust manifold to the cat, it might help a bit, but I would worry about moisture getting trapped between the wrap and the exhaust components and rusting out the pipes prematurely..

    What I did is line the hood with a layer of that foil+bubblewrap insulation and blocked off the radiator except for a small hole over just the small hybrid radiator. When it really starts to get cold, I'll probably close off the hole as there will be enough losses without the extra air flow.. In any case, what this has accomplished is that the car warms up slightly faster, seems to have a bit more power as the warm air stays in the engine compartment- intake air is 15-20C above ambient, and after even a short drive, although the outside of the hood is cold, the engine compartment is nice and warm (without the radiator block and hood insulation, in cold or cool weather, the engine would barely be warm, even after a lengthy drive)..

    The one caution would be to to get watch the temperatures closely- a Miniscanner, Scangauge or similar diagnostic device should be attached to watch engine temperature readings until the real cold weather arrives..

    The hack/mod I'd love to see is something to disable the "warm-up" mode- the concensus seems to be that the fastest way to warm up a car is to simply drive it, so a mode that forces idling in a fuel-and-power inefficient valve-timing mode is IMO rather useless.. I'd rather have the car start and stop the engine even when cold and let us "just drive".. I'd bet that you'd get *fewer* overall emissions when cold by not doing this warm-up, allowing the ICE to proceed normally under load and to allow normal shut down at stops instead of wasteful idling in a rather futile attempt to try to keep the tiny little engine hot (indeed, most people in cold climates report that the ICE seldom stops in the winter, preferring instead to idle away like regular cars)..

    Unfortunately, my first attempt at this hack (fake a 70C reading on the coolant temperature sensor) failed (got a MIL and P3191 and P3101 codes) probably due to some other cross-checks that the computer does.. Strange because the service manual implies that even if the coolant temp. sensor fails, it's supposed to assume a fail-safe value of 80C.. Anyone have any insights?? Maybe just disconnecting the sensor vs. fooling it??
     
  4. Lather

    Lather New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 25, 2005
    27
    0
    0
    So why does a Prius need a hot tailpipe to make it happy?

    Yeah, I know what I said. And I’m as sick and twisted as you are. But I digress.

    The exhaust gases are hot. If they get cold, they become dense and heavy. It takes more energy to push the exhaust gases through. Some people wrap their entire exhaust system for performance. It seems to me that it would increase efficiency as well.

    Also, I notice that my worst mileage is during the first five minutes. If I insulated the exhaust, I would expect it to warm up quicker and stay warmer in the winter (and summer). People are running block heaters, they’re blocking off the radiator and carpeting the engine compartment to keep the block warm. They’re fabricating warm air intakes. Aren’t we ignoring the second biggest heatsink in the system? (a long temperature exchanging tube with cold air running over it at 30-70mph) If we can brag up a thermos bottle, wouldn’t this make sense?

    But then again, I’m used to being wrong. And I really don’t want to rust out my exhaust. And I doubt if many people want it this hot: http://www.aqtd29.dsl.pipex.com/bigtone.wmv
     
  5. Frank Hudon

    Frank Hudon Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jan 11, 2004
    4,147
    19
    0
    with the CANVIEW scanner I see that the coolant flush from the thermous gets the temp to about 55C for the time it takes the ICE to start then it almost immeadiatly drops to low 30's C (OAT 15C) then the ICE runs till the temp gets back up to 70C for S4. It's also my understanding that the Prius ICE runs from a cold state, in retarded timing mode with a slightly rich mixture to get the cat's up to temp fast. On the MiniScanner in my Classic the output from the O2 sensors starts to rise almost upon starting. I doubt that wrapping the manifold would have much of an effect, also wrapping the Cat's would probably cause the monolith inside of them to melt, as the heat would probably get to high. If you had a cat failure because of he wrap I doubt that you'd get warranty on it. There are likley more sensors that tell the computers what state the temps are and what has all happened since the last time the car was started. There are thermistor buried in the MG's and in the Inverter. This is pretty well protecting the car from you by the sounds of it.
     
  6. Frank Hudon

    Frank Hudon Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jan 11, 2004
    4,147
    19
    0
    C4 have you considered a rheostat that you could adjust over a period of say 20 seconds that would tell the computer that the ICE has reached 70+C. By disconnecting the temp sender the computer probably thinks the system has a problem and sets the MIL. This would also give the computer some time to see things like the O2 sensors working etc. Possibly a 555 that latches a resistor to trick the computer then when the temp sensor sends a value higher than whats going to the computer the 555 shuts off till the next start. Just a thought.
     
  7. Lather

    Lather New Member

    Joined:
    Sep 25, 2005
    27
    0
    0
    Thanks Frank, I appreciate your and C4’s responses.

    Anyway, are you referring to warm start rather than a cold/first start in the morning? Have you tracked the changes in the winter versus the summer? I’d really be interested in what the engine is doing depending upon ambient temperature.

    I wouldn’t think that wrapping the cats would harm them. If you can wrap a V-8 cat I
    doubt if you could harm the cats on a 1.5L part time engine. If anything, I would expect to work better and last longer.

    Frank & C4: Is tricking the computer the best bet? I’d rather control the environment, if that’s possible. If I removed the exhaust, painted it w/ header paint and wrapped it; as a $50 mod, would it be worth it?

    I gotta get something like CANVIEW. I’ve been looking at a few CAN options but I’ve only had the car 3 weeks. I've got 1200 bucks into it so far, $25 in gas.
     
  8. hobbit

    hobbit Senior Member

    Joined:
    Mar 23, 2005
    4,089
    468
    0
    Location:
    Bahstahn
    Vehicle:
    2004 Prius
    Model:
    N/A
    You probably don't want to mess with the cats, and just consider
    that heat loss as protecting them. [Cats get really unhappy when
    you try to wrap them up, right??]
    .
    I've been playing with a warm-air intake redirect, but I won't really
    know its effect on mileage until the weather gets colder. It's just
    a piece of cheap NAPA heat-riser hose [probably to replace those ol'
    lines running up to air cleaners atop chevy big-blocks..] sent back
    over the engine and into a piece of larger tubing [dryer hose],
    whose end tucks around under the edge of the heat shield over the
    exhaust header. Seems to collect fairly warm air from back there
    and effectively recycle it -- heck, I've already generated those
    BTUs, why not try to re-use them, right? May play with radiator
    blockoffs later. But retention of heat in various ways has plenty
    of merit as an efficiency idea, as long as it doesn't present risk
    to components.
    .
    _H*
     
  9. storm petrol

    storm petrol Member

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    106
    17
    0
    Location:
    44 degrees, 42 minutes North; 73 degrees, 29 minu
    Vehicle:
    2017 Prius Prime
    Model:
    Prime Advanced
    Hello,

    I would really like to be able to monitor coolant temp on my '05. It is really the only way I would feel comfortable about playing with limiting air flow throught the radiator, or other more exotic attempts to increase the speed of warm up.

    I am not a real auto tech, but I used to do my own valves on my '67 VW. I also replaced the muffler on that sucker a couple times, which was a solid afternoon of work!

    Is there a simple way to make this monitoring happen?


    storm petrol
     
  10. c4

    c4 Active Member

    Joined:
    Mar 29, 2005
    607
    51
    0
    Frank- based on the schematics, my first attempt at the cold-start defeat mod was hooking up a potentiometer in parallel to the temp sensor (the idea was the lowest temp the ECM would see would be 70C, but if it rose above that, the proper reading would be reflected), but what I did was to switch the car to Ig-On where I adjusted the potentiometer up and down and monitored the reported temperature readings to figure out the range of adjustment, and then I set it to a reading of 70C. I then proceeded to start the car (without first switching it off). The engine started, ran about 5 seconds, and shut off, then a second later, the MIL came on.

    Two possible explanations come to mind: 1) because I twiddled the potentiometer and made the temperature range go up and down quickly while the ECM was powered up, and then proceeded to start the car without first powering off, the ECM saw the apparent temperature fluctuations and got intself into a strange mode and this is what caused the MIL.. 2) There's additional logic in the ECM that tries to cross-check the temperature reading with timers and other sensors, and something about an instantaneous 70C reading was inconsistent with these other readings..

    I can easily see if explanation #1 is the reason by setting the temp, then turning the system off before attempting to start and seeing if it still triggers an MIL.. The reason I wanted to pull the sensor input entirely is to see the behaviour of the system in the event of a sensor failure... Again, the repair manual says that it's supposed to assume a fail-safe value of 80C for coolant temperature if the sensor fails.. There's a specific code for coolant temperature sensor malfunction, but I did *NOT* get this code, instead, I got the generic hybrid failure codes (P3101 and P3191). I basically want to know if pulling the sensor gets the desired result when spoofing the reading does not..

    In terms of explanation #2, if there's a consistency check, I'm somewhat at a loss because as far as I can tell from looking at the vehicle schematics, there's only two ICE temperature sensors: 1) the coolant temperature sensor and 2) the intake air temperature sensor. The IAT is simply used to control the mixture,so the coolant temperature should be the only sensor responsible for measuring engine temperature.. The hybrid portion has its own temperature sensors and cooling system but these should be independent of the ICE cold-start function (and indeed, the thermos only collects ICE coolant, so it's very much possible for the ICE to get rewarmed by the thermos while the hybrid is cold).. Setting a fixed coolant temperature of 70C should theoretically be fine as it basically reflect the following real-world scenaro: you've been driving around and the system is at temperature, then you stop and shut the system down and then come back shortly- the coolant temperature should still be quite high and the system should use it's "abbreviated" cold start sequence (ie, engine runs for about 30 seconds and then shutdown is allowed). The cat may or may not have cooled in this situation but this shouldn't affect the function either: I believe the O2 sensors are narrow band, so the ECM should only be able to derive a binary reading (cat hot or cat cold)..

    I'm definitely going to try again- the last time, I had an appointment to go to, so I didn't spend a whole lot of time attempting other things after the initial failure (instead, I concentrated on getting the car back to normal, but this really should be a doable mod- I can't see why it shouldn't work as intended..

    Lather- I'm of the opinion that the computer spoof is the most effective solution.. The amount of environmental change you can implement is rather limited: it's difficult to control Mother Nature, but a computer behaves in a well-defined manner based on its inputs, so if you can just figure out which inputs to change, you can change the behaviour of the system.. You might improve the cat warm-up by a minute by wrapping the exhaust, but in comparison, if you ca figure out the right sensor(s) to spoof, you can completely eliminate the wasteful "cold start" procedure..
     
  11. Frank Hudon

    Frank Hudon Senior Member

    Joined:
    Jan 11, 2004
    4,147
    19
    0
    C4 it might be possible to spoof the computer to think that the ICE is still at 70+C and bypass the cold start routine. You might be on to something with leaving the rheostat in the circuit set to whatever gives 70C. I wonder if the hybrid computer on the battery side which has a circuit to determine the time off and time on is not the culpret that's triggering the MIL by saying it's been off for X hours and the ICE should be cold. I doubt that the intake air temp is the problem here, it's probably used to get the fuel ratio right for the temp and amount of oxygen in it for combustion. Cold air=more dense ie: more O2 warm/hot air less dense=less O2 so it trims the fuel flow to get the best mixture. The inverter temp and the battey temps are probably also a contributing factor in the computer logic to get the car warmed up as quick as possible. Another thought if the PTC heaters are triggured would that have an effect on it as well. Better question is can anyone reverse engineer the codes in all the computers and tell us what is happening and when?
     
  12. ken1784

    ken1784 SuperMID designer

    Joined:
    Dec 18, 2003
    2,943
    1,378
    67
    Location:
    Yokohama, JAPAN
    Vehicle:
    2010 Prius
    Model:
    N/A
    Yes.
    You can check the THW(coolant temparature signal) voltage at the Pin 19 of A connecter of engine ECU by volt meter.

    It is not a linear conversion. The conversion table is shown at...
    http://priuschat.com/index.php?showtopic=7494&st=21

    Ken@Japan
     
  13. storm petrol

    storm petrol Member

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2005
    106
    17
    0
    Location:
    44 degrees, 42 minutes North; 73 degrees, 29 minu
    Vehicle:
    2017 Prius Prime
    Model:
    Prime Advanced
    Ken,

    Thank you for that info.

    Now, can you direct me to any instructions as to where pin 19 is physically located? Would I use any voltmeter that I would pick up at my local auto parts place? Could I leave this in place for continuous monitoring as I drive?

    Sorry about the endless questions, but do you know why Toyota did not put a temp gauge into an option package?

    Thanks,

    storm petrol
     
  14. ken1784

    ken1784 SuperMID designer

    Joined:
    Dec 18, 2003
    2,943
    1,378
    67
    Location:
    Yokohama, JAPAN
    Vehicle:
    2010 Prius
    Model:
    N/A
    The engine ECU is located behind the globe box.
    You can refer to the following EV button installation article about the location.
    http://www.priuschat.com/forums/kb.php?mode=article&k=5

    The article is for the Hybrid ECU, but you'll find the engine ECU next to the Hybrid ECU at the procedure (6).

    The THW signal is pin-19 of E4 connector.
    Please refer to the attaced picture.
    You can get a voltmeter any place you want, such as Radio Shack.
    Sure, you can monitor the voltage during driving, no problem.
    I think the reason is a cost.
    A normal driver does not care about the coolant temp. :)

    Ken@Japan