Featured Prius, Tesla and other, 23 most dangerous cars

So this is the latest FARS data for 2022 in comma delimited format:

crashes, days, fatalities, make(model)
01, 00345, 01, Acura (ILX)
01, 00309, 01, Acura (RDX)
02, 00467, 02, Aprilia (RS)
01, 00288, 01, Aprilia (Tuono)
02, 00541, 02, Aprilia (RS)
01, 00193, 01, Audi (A4)
01, 00201, 01, Audi (Q5)
01, 00225, 01, Audi (Q3)
01, 00171, 01, BAODIAO (2 lines)
01, 00175, 01, Benelli (TNT)
02, 00210, 03, BMW (M3)
01, 00299, 01, BMW (M550i)
02, 00238, 02, BMW (740Li)
02, 00522, 02, BMW (840i)
02, 00291, 02, BMW (430i)
01, 00308, 01, BMW (228i)
02, 00450, 04, BMW (X3)
01, 00355, 01, BMW (G 310 R)
01, 00184, 01, BMW (S 1000 R)
02, 00343, 02, BMW (S 1000 RR)
06, 01309, 07, Buick (Encore GX)
01, 00107, 01, Buick (Envision)
01, 00097, 01, Cadillac (XT5)
01, 00161, 01, Cadillac (Escalade)
01, 00161, 01, CAN-AM (Spyder F3)
01, 00259, 01, CAN-AM (Spyder RT)
03, 00653, 03, CAN-AM (Ryker)
01, 00340, 01, CAN-AM (Defender/Traxter)
02, 00548, 02, CAN-AM (Maverick)
01, 00246, 01, CAN-AM (Outlander)
01, 00246, 01, CAN-AM (Maverick)
01, 00144, 01, CFMOTO (CF300)
01, 00210, 01, CFMOTO (CF700)
01, 00326, 01, CFMOTO (CFORCE)
03, 00707, 04, Chevrolet (Corvette)
03, 01699, 04, Chevrolet (Camaro)
01, 00356, 01, Chevrolet (Spark)
07, 01613, 09, Chevrolet (Malibu)
01, 00256, 01, Chevrolet (Bolt EV)
07, 01834, 08, Chevrolet (Equinox)
01, 00037, 01, Chevrolet (Trax)
01, 00705, 01, Chevrolet (Traverse)
04, 00407, 04, Chevrolet (Colorado)
06, 01095, 06, Chevrolet (Silverado LTD)
01, 00312, 01, Chevrolet (Silverado HD)
06, 01621, 08, Chevrolet (Silverado)
01, 00218, 01, Chevrolet (Blazer)
05, 00868, 05, Chevrolet (Trailblazer)
02, 00432, 02, Chevrolet (Silverado HD)
02, 00567, 02, Chrysler (300)
03, 00841, 04, Chrysler (Pacifica)
04, 01234, 07, Dodge (Charger)
02, 00372, 02, Dodge (Challenger)
01, 00363, 01, Dodge (Durango)
01, 00666, 01, Ducati (Desert X)
02, 00392, 02, Ducati (Diavel/XDiavel)
01, 00065, 01, Ducati (Streetfighter)
01, 00133, 01, Ducati (Panigale)
02, 00968, 02, Ducati (Multistrada)
01, 00168, 01, Ducati (Superbike)
01, 00249, 01, Ducati (Monster)
01, 00258, 01, FENGYUAN (GTX)
01, 00325, 01, Ford (Escape)
01, 00301, 02, Ford (Ecosport)
01, 00354, 01, Ford (Expedition MAX)
02, 00315, 02, Ford (Edge)
05, 01552, 05, Ford (Explorer)
01, 00284, 01, Ford (Transit)
01, 00288, 01, Ford (Ranger)
04, 01202, 04, Ford (F-250)
04, 00891, 04, Ford (F-150)
02, 00670, 02, Ford (Maverick)
02, 00607, 02, Ford (Bronco Sport)
01, 00356, 01, Ford (Bronco)
02, 00518, 02, Ford (E-350)
02, 00603, 02, Ford (F-350)
01, 00306, 01, Ford (F-650)
01, 00291, 01, Freightliner (114SD)
24, 06101, 24, Freightliner (Cascadia)
01, 00681, 01, Freightliner (MT 55G )
02, 00520, 02, Freightliner (MT 45G )
04, 01953, 04, Freightliner (M2)
01, 00613, 01, Freightliner (B2 Bus Chassis)
02, 00324, 03, GENESIS (G70)
02, 00460, 02, Genuine Scooters (Buddy (50, 125, 170i))
03, 01307, 04, GMC (Terrain)
01, 00315, 01, GMC (Yukon)
01, 00251, 01, GMC (Acadia)
02, 00324, 02, GMC (Sierra Limited)
01, 00299, 01, GMC (Sierra)
02, 00277, 02, GMC (Sierra HD)
02, 00469, 02, Harley Davidson (FLTRKSE )
02, 00648, 02, Harley Davidson (FLTRXST / Road Glide ST)
04, 00989, 05, Harley Davidson (FLHXST / Street Glide ST)
07, 01039, 07, Harley Davidson (FXBBS / Street Bob)
01, 00037, 01, Harley Davidson (Sportster)
01, 00303, 01, Harley Davidson (RA1250 / Pan America)
01, 00100, 01, Harley Davidson (FLTRK / Road Glide Limited)
06, 01290, 06, Harley Davidson (FXLRS / Low Rider S)
01, 00230, 01, Harley Davidson (FLHT / Electra Glide Standard)
01, 00249, 01, Harley Davidson (FLTRXSE / CVO Road Glide)
01, 00266, 01, Harley Davidson (FXFBS / Fat Bob 114)
01, 00090, 01, Harley Davidson (FLFBS / Fat Boy 114)
02, 00594, 02, Harley Davidson (FLHCS / Heritage Classic 114)
02, 00521, 02, Harley Davidson (FLHRXS / Road King Special)
01, 00241, 01, Harley Davidson (FLHXSE / CVO Street Glide)
01, 00258, 01, Harley Davidson (FLRT / Freewheeler)
01, 00223, 01, Harley Davidson (FLHTCUTG / Tri Glide Ultra)
05, 00995, 05, Harley Davidson (FLTRXS / Road Glide Special)
05, 01271, 05, Harley Davidson (FLTRX / Road Glide)
03, 00704, 03, Harley Davidson (FLHXS / Street Glide Special)
02, 00288, 02, Harley Davidson (FLHX / Street Glide)
01, 00350, 01, Harley Davidson (FLHTP / Police Electra Glide)
02, 00473, 02, Harley Davidson (FLHTK / ULTRA LIMITED)
01, 00222, 01, Harley Davidson (FLHR / Road King)
06, 01276, 06, Harley Davidson (XL883N / IRON 883)
01, 00176, 01, Harley Davidson (Street Glide)
10, 01717, 10, Honda (Civic)
04, 01130, 05, Honda (Accord)
09, 02206, 09, Honda (CR-V)
04, 01155, 05, Honda (HR-V)
02, 00575, 02, Honda (Pilot)
01, 00170, 01, Honda (Passport)
03, 01110, 04, Honda (Odyssey)
01, 00362, 01, Honda (Ridgeline)
01, 00644, 01, Honda (Ruckus)
03, 00538, 03, Honda (NCW50/Metropolitan)
02, 00575, 02, Honda (Navi)
01, 00220, 01, Honda (Monkey)
02, 00601, 02, Honda (MSX125 (Grom))
01, 00301, 01, Honda (CRF300L)
01, 00170, 01, Honda (ADV150)
01, 00236, 01, Honda (CBF300)
02, 00644, 02, Honda (CMX300 (Rebel 300))
01, 00243, 01, Honda (CRF250)
02, 00273, 02, Honda (CRF450)
06, 01392, 06, Honda (CMX500 (Rebel500))
02, 00434, 02, Honda (CBR600)
02, 00446, 02, Honda (VT750 (Shadow Phantom))
01, 00333, 01, Honda (VT750 (Shadow Aero))
01, 00221, 01, Honda (NC750X)
02, 00525, 02, Honda (CBR500)
01, 00273, 01, Honda (CB500)
03, 00818, 03, Honda (CMX1100D (REBEL1100 DCT))
01, 00280, 01, Honda (CMX1100A (REBEL1100))
05, 01241, 05, Honda (CBR1000)
01, 00127, 01, Honda (TRX250)
01, 00294, 01, Honda (TRX500 (Rubicon))
02, 00475, 03, Honda (TRX420)
01, 00234, 01, Husqvarna (Closed Course Competition)
02, 00459, 02, Husqvarna (Svartpilen/Vitpilen)
02, 00395, 04, Hyundai (Sonata)
01, 00343, 01, Hyundai (Elantra N)
12, 04572, 15, Hyundai (Elantra)
05, 01166, 06, Hyundai (Santa Fe)
06, 01404, 07, Hyundai (Tucson)
01, 00169, 02, Hyundai (Kona N)
06, 01847, 06, Hyundai (Kona)
01, 00273, 01, Hyundai (Venue)
01, 00042, 01, Hyundai (Palisade)
01, 00232, 01, Hyundai (SANTA CRUZ)
01, 00216, 01, IC Bus (PB105)
01, 00189, 01, Indian Motorcycle (Scout Bobber Twenty)
03, 00586, 03, Indian Motorcycle (FTR)
03, 00661, 03, Indian Motorcycle (Indian Challenger)
01, 00293, 01, Indian Motorcycle (Scout)
01, 00502, 01, Indian Motorcycle (Chief)
01, 00276, 01, International (LS532)
04, 01036, 04, International (MV607)
04, 01997, 05, International (LT625)
01, 00065, 01, International (HX520)
05, 01227, 05, Jeep (Wrangler)
01, 00233, 02, Jeep (Cherokee)
01, 00250, 01, Jeep (Renegade)
02, 00464, 02, Jeep (Grand Cherokee)
02, 00403, 05, Jeep (Gladiator)
01, 00358, 02, Jeep (Wagoneer)
01, 00252, 01, Jeep (Grand Wagoneer)
01, 00124, 01, Jeep (Compass)
01, 00234, 01, Jiajue (JJ150T-40)
04, 00857, 04, Kawasaki (KLX)
03, 00756, 03, Kawasaki (Z125 PRO)
01, 00274, 01, Kawasaki (KLX140)
02, 00292, 02, Kawasaki (Z400)
15, 03669, 16, Kawasaki (Ninja 400)
02, 00452, 02, Kawasaki (KX450)
06, 01052, 06, Kawasaki (KL650)
04, 00849, 04, Kawasaki (Z650)
18, 05562, 18, Kawasaki (ZX-6R)
01, 00164, 01, Kawasaki (Vulcan S)
14, 02886, 14, Kawasaki (Ninja 650)
02, 00333, 02, Kawasaki (Ninja ZX-6R)
01, 00239, 01, Kawasaki (Z H2)
04, 00855, 04, Kawasaki (Z900)
01, 00099, 01, Kawasaki (Ninja ZX-14)
02, 00449, 02, Kawasaki (Ninja ZX-10R)
01, 00258, 01, Kenworth (W990)
01, 00284, 01, Kenworth (T880)
05, 01349, 07, Kenworth (T680)
01, 00108, 01, Kenworth (W9 Series)
02, 00621, 02, Kenworth (T3 Series)
01, 00188, 01, Kia (Rio)
09, 03015, 10, Kia (Forte)
01, 00161, 01, Kia (Stinger)
04, 01283, 04, Kia (K5)
08, 02556, 12, Kia (Sportage)
03, 01132, 03, Kia (Sorento)
01, 00317, 01, Kia (Niro)
02, 00544, 02, Kia (Telluride)
03, 01069, 03, Kia (Carnival)
01, 00180, 01, Kia (Seltos)
06, 01849, 06, Kia (Soul)
01, 00296, 01, KTM (DUKE)
01, 00292, 01, KTM (RC)
01, 00292, 01, KTM (Street Legal Enduro)
01, 00161, 01, KTM (Super Adventure)
01, 00119, 01, Lamborghini (Huracan)
01, 00201, 01, Lexus (RX)
02, 00628, 02, Lexus (GX)
01, 00287, 01, Lincoln (Corsair)
01, 00175, 01, LiveWire (LiveWire One)
01, 00364, 02, Lucid Motors (Lucid Air)
04, 01077, 04, Mack (Anthem)
01, 00100, 01, Mack (LR)
01, 00129, 01, Massimo Motor Sports (MB Mini Bike)
02, 00482, 02, Mazda (Mazda3)
01, 00321, 02, Mazda (CX-5)
01, 00711, 01, Mazda (CX-9)
02, 00533, 03, Mercedes-Benz (C-Class)
03, 00785, 03, Mercedes-Benz (GLC-Class)
01, 00223, 01, Mercedes-Benz (Sprinter)
01, 00064, 01, Mitsubishi (Mirage G4)
01, 00101, 01, Mitsubishi (Mirage)
01, 00601, 01, Mitsubishi (ECLIPSE CROSS)
06, 01321, 07, Mitsubishi (Outlander)
01, 00307, 02, Nissan (Maxima)
05, 01289, 06, Nissan (Sentra)
13, 02745, 18, Nissan (Altima)
01, 00154, 04, Nissan (Versa)
02, 00618, 02, Nissan (Kicks)
01, 00354, 01, Nissan (Rogue Sport)
02, 00424, 03, Nissan (Pathfinder)
03, 01238, 03, Nissan (Rogue)
02, 00461, 02, Nissan (Murano)
03, 00881, 03, Nissan (Frontier)
01, 00310, 01, ONYX Motorcycles (ONYX)
01, 00292, 01, Peterbilt (389)
02, 00205, 02, Peterbilt (579)
01, 00345, 01, Phat Custom Cycles (Phat Custom Cycles)
01, 00196, 01, Piaggio and Vespa (VESPA Primavera / Sprint 150)
01, 00307, 01, Polaris (GENERAL)
02, 00683, 02, Polaris (Sportsman)
05, 01281, 05, Polaris (Ranger)
05, 01343, 07, Polaris (RZR)
02, 00522, 03, Porsche (911)
16, 03070, 20, Ram (1500)
01, 00199, 01, Royal Enfield (INT 650)
01, 00349, 01, Slingshot (Slingshot)
02, 00439, 02, Subaru (Impreza)
02, 00558, 02, Subaru (WRX)
02, 00500, 02, Subaru (Forester)
05, 02214, 05, Subaru (Crosstrek)
01, 00311, 01, Subaru (Outback)
02, 00399, 02, Suzuki (DR-Z400SM)
01, 00225, 01, Suzuki (DR-Z400S)
01, 00180, 01, Suzuki (GSX-S750)
01, 00247, 01, Suzuki (DR650S)
03, 00727, 03, Suzuki (GSX-R600)
02, 01422, 02, Suzuki (Hayabusa)
04, 00687, 04, Suzuki (GSX1300RRM2)
05, 00684, 05, Suzuki (GSX-R750)
04, 00685, 04, Suzuki (GSX-R1000R)
01, 00332, 01, Suzuki (GSX750F/GSX750FT)
01, 00133, 01, Suzuki (LT-A750 / King Quad 750)
01, 00235, 01, TAOTAO (PONY)
03, 00724, 03, TAOTAO (QUANTUM (TITAN))
01, 00313, 01, TAOTAO (LANCER (EAGLE))
05, 00976, 06, Tesla (Model Y)
09, 02649, 10, Tesla (Model 3)
01, 00254, 01, Tesla (Model X)
06, 01050, 08, Tesla (Model S)
01, 00113, 01, TEYIN (TY50SRT)
01, 00325, 01, TEYIN (Falcon)
18, 03797, 21, Toyota (Corolla)
14, 02889, 15, Toyota (Camry)
01, 00187, 01, Toyota (Avalon)
02, 00389, 03, Toyota (PRIUS)
01, 00267, 01, Toyota (Supra)
01, 00293, 01, Toyota (GR86)
03, 00693, 06, Toyota (4-Runner)
08, 02203, 08, Toyota (RAV4)
05, 00899, 06, Toyota (Highlander)
01, 00361, 01, Toyota (C-HR)
02, 00492, 04, Toyota (Sienna)
03, 00761, 03, Toyota (Tacoma)
01, 00218, 01, Triumph (Tiger)
01, 00151, 01, Triumph (Trident)
02, 00236, 02, Triumph (Bonneville)
01, 00163, 01, Triumph (Tiger)
01, 00352, 01, Vanderhall Motor Works (Venice)
01, 00235, 01, Volkswagen (Jetta)
03, 00560, 03, Volkswagen (Tiguan)
01, 00256, 01, Volkswagen (Atlas Cross Sport 4Motion)
01, 00222, 02, Volkswagen (Atlas)
01, 00251, 01, Volkswagen (Taos 4Motion)
01, 00340, 01, Volvo (XC90)
09, 02562, 10, Volvo Truck (VNL)
01, 00547, 01, Western Star (49X Chassis)
01, 00156, 01, Yamaha (MTN320)
11, 02364, 11, Yamaha (YZF690)
07, 01910, 07, Yamaha (MTN690)
02, 00589, 02, Yamaha (MTN890)
04, 01092, 04, Yamaha (YZF-R1)
01, 00185, 01, Yamaha (YZ450F)
01, 00309, 01, Yamaha (YXZ1000)
01, 00119, 01, Yamaha (YFM700 (Raptor 700))
08, 01938, 08, Yongfu (YN50QT; YN150T; YN250T)
08, 01976, 08, ZNEN (ZN50QT/ ZN150T)

Lessons learned from earlier spreadsheet. Check it again in the morning.

Bob Wilson

 

So just to confirm my thinking…

Car A sells 10 cars which comes out to 365 days/year x 10 cars = 3650 days driven in one year.
If there were 5 deaths that year, you would get 3650 days/5 deaths = 730 days/death.

I was thinking deaths/miles driven would be far better. However, if mileage is simply an estimate, and is the same estimate for all cars, then days seems just as valid as miles (maybe more).

If you drive a lot, your personal risk would be higher. Likewise, if you are on the roads less than average, your risk goes down.

It’s similar to the EPA. It gives a good comparative base of different vehicles. Your personal results may vary

 

This is what iseecars is trying to measure here.

 

Yes - in a somewhat non sequitur disjointed way.
.

 

Close. The 'days' is exact because I only use cars of the model year 2022 and higher. Some manufacturers upgrade their model year in September.

Never forget these are only the cars, motorcycles, and trucks involved in 2022 fatal accidents. I have no information about the total number of cars that were not in fatal accidents or accident free. But Tesla makes this easy ... for Teslas.

The Tesla Q1, Q2, Q3, and Q4 financial reports have Model 3/Model Y and Model S/Model X production numbers. A feasible basis of estimate would use 1/2 the days in a quarter times the production numbers in that quarter plus full quarter days from the earlier quarters. But without similar metrics for the other vendors, it is more 'grins and giggles' than useful.

For me, we have an understanding how many actual fatal accidents occur in the first year of ownership:

• Motorcycles are deadly!
• For to 23 cars and pickup trucks

fatalities make(model)
21 Toyota (Corolla)
20 Ram (1500)
18 Nissan (Altima)
15 Hyundai (Elantra)
15 Toyota (Camry)
12 Kia (Sportage)
10 Honda (Civic)
10 Kia (Forte)
10 Tesla (Model 3)
9 Chevrolet (Malibu)
9 Honda (CR-V)
8 Chevrolet (Equinox)
8 Chevrolet (Silverado)
8 Tesla (Model S)
8 Toyota (RAV4)
7 Buick (Encore GX)
7 Dodge (Charger)
7 Hyundai (Tucson)
7 Mitsubishi (Outlander)
6 Chevrolet (Silverado LTD)
6 Honda (CMX500 (Rebel500))
6 Hyundai (Santa Fe)
6 Hyundai (Kona)

Since the Model 3 and Model S show up in the top 23 list excluding motorcycles and trucks, I can't rule out the earlier claim.

Bob Wilson

 

Whether the study has errors aside, I think many are misunderstanding what they were measuring. The number of deaths for a model they are presenting isn't just counting the occupants that died in the crash. It is also including the deaths of other people involved in said crash. A model that has zero fatalities to drivers and passengers, but kills every pedestrian, biker, and everyone else in the other car that it hits is going to have a poor rating by this measurement while getting high scores in traditional methods.

 

The buyer has a list of priorities and occupants that have a higher priority than those who did not help buy that car. But this is a brutal way to restate the 'Problem of the Commons.'

Bob Wilson

 

I think that is more of a justification than a real reason.
SUVs tend to have higher occurances of roll overs. Extra mass will actually work against you vs stationary objects.

Convenience is why many people like SUVs.

 

I don't think this is actually what is being measured.

Garbage in means garbage out. They are guestimating some milage that is based on 2 years of new cars, based on them being sold as used. Why not just make up all the numbers if the methodology is all flawed. And that is what you get garbage.

people don't like musk. Some because they don't like evs, some because they don't like trump, others because they hate billioniers. But the cars are not musk, nad there needs to be some repeated valid methodology. iseecars is click bait. Believe the fars database but not the iseecars misuse of the data.

That used to be the case. With electroniv nanies and many subs being car like most roll over accidents are prevented. You can still do it but it is harder

 

Pickup trucks and SUVs have taken over the roadways and their bumpers don't line up with passenger cars.

 

Agree iseecars studies are garbage, but they aren't picking on Musk, Tesla, or EVs. There are 5 'deadilier' models on their list than the Model Y, and they all have an ICE.

I was contesting the opening statement of the preceding video that people in a Tesla are 3.7 times more likely to die. iseecars is using FARS for number of deaths. They say they looked at crashes that had "one occupant fatality to identify the most dangerous vehicles on U.S. roads today". That criteria can include crashes where the Tesla occupants were fine.

Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) | NHTSA

 

You should just ask your parents to enable videos

Mike