new 2010 vs. used 2008, thoughts?

One other thing you might want to look into (do not know even if it is a possibility, but...) - if you prefer the Gen II, what are prices like on a new *2009*? My guess is, since everyone wants a '10, you might be able to get a good deal and have the new car warranty advantages.

Also, just as an aside, I'm not that impressed with the backup camera. My parents have an '08 with one (great car, no complaints), and whenever I use it backing into a parking spot, the car behind looks to be about seven miles away until the bumpers tap, at which point it still looks about a foot away. I guess it's better for seeing in a wide-angle way what's around the back of the car. In any case, rear visibility isn't a strong suit of any Prius I know. Just my $0.02. Good luck again on your decision.

T

 

I forgot the most important thing for me. I guess you guys forgot too or it is not important for you.

10,000 mile oil changes for 2010.

For me, it is a no brainer assuming the 10,000 oil change is really coming. I"ll pay anything to not see the stealership.

For me, the 2010 is the only choice - now that I thought of the 10K oil change.

 

The 2008 in question is roughly a 2010 Prius III but they are completely different cars. The III won't have the camera & 3 door SKS (useful to me). You'll have to spend some time in the 2010 to evaluate the differences for yourself. IMO if the prices are close then new is better than old but if the 2008 is a better fit for you then buy it.

 

I would not buy one car over another just because of a backup camera. A wireless backup camera can be added for not too much, although some report fading of view (don't know how true that is).

It sure seems the 'Gen2' Prius driver seating cockpit was not designed for anyone over about 5'8" or 5'9" and notice I said 'designed'. Sure, there's the ones at 6'3" that claim good comfort, but at 6'2" I hate driving the car because of the cramped seating. I didn't really realize how bad it was until sitting in the few small-mid cars with spacious seating like Honda Civics and the new Prius. But the Gen2 Prius seat is an oxymoron (sp?) because it has quality construction but has a terrible shape and lack of adjustment.

The 2010 is obviously more car with a few less amenities. But, it's tough with it being the first year model and having some apparent bugaboos.

 

Don't forget the 2010 comes with New Car Smell!

 

Second hand car no matter how well looked after it can never be as immaculate as a new one.
Only $2,000 difference it is no brainer to get the new Prius. It looks better and everything else is more refined. It is not as if the new model is worse than the older version.
Personally I am very puzzled with the question because it is not a question one would ask normally because don't think anyone will be even considering buying a older one for that price compared to a new car.

 

You make a great case for the 08. It has the soft material panels that is lacking in the 2010. You get higher resolution MFD screen.

Have you check out the insurance rate for both?

 

Check out Amica. I switched from Geico (loyal customer for 10 years) and knocked off 40%.

Why not look for another 06 similar to your old Prius, so you won't have to pay much extra?

 

Congrats! Let us know how you like 2010 better. Did you get the Prius II?

 

Did you have the Clean Pass HOV lane sticker on your old car? I was wondering what you do now... will they give you a new sticker with the same number or will you have to apply for a new sticker?

 

I thought that's only in CA. When that day comes, our stickers will be worth $2-3k.

 

Is the 2010 Prius II price of $22,917 OTD or just MSRP?

 

Congrats with your new purchase. Enjoy it in good health.