Start a new thread or bring up old one?

Depending on what the question is, I decide to post a new thread or revive an old one. You just have to use judgement on whether the subject needs to be updated or if the "old" info is still valid. Its probably not as much of an issue in the gen3 section since its only been a 1.5 years since its release. I know on other forums where cars have much more history, the topic comes up a lot more.

 

I try to answer completely, THEN point out that there have been dozens/hundreds/thousands of similar threads, with the same answers.

http://priuschat.com/forums/gen-ii-...ars-my-main-battery-will-die.html#post1188333

as an example.

 

i tend to graze thru new posts and always find it funny when i click on an interesting one and find out it's a few years old and somebody has decided to tack on another post. you are right though, sometimes they are relevent and sometimes not.

 

It's a judgement call. If your post is a clear continuation of a dormant discussion, then by all means revive it. If it's the same question we've answered a thousand times, like 'which tires?', then you bear some responsibility to at least read what's already been written. Usually, even the people who respond by saying RTFM are somewhat nice about it. If it's a genuinely stupid question, be prepared to be told. None of us speak for everybody - you're bound to get a wide range of opinion and reaction.

 

This question has been asked a thousand times already - use the search function.



Sorry, I couldn't resist posting that. As others stated, there isn't any one correct answer. If the old thread is still relevant and fits your question, post there. Otherwise start a new one.

We do try to answer all of the questions, even the ones posted over and over. Sometimes it is obvious that the poster failed to make even a half-hearted attempt to search out an answer. It's hard not to be a bit testy in that situation.

Tom

 

I find lots of Gems in the old threads as peps answer a 2yr old question. I think lots just don't look at the date and they were searching for something. Bravo to putting new info in an old thread and NOT starting another. Every, EVERY time I think I have a new question, I search (which takes more than 10 seconds) and I find it. As well doing a bing or google search answers the question in a non prius answer such as paint, or oil weight. The tire, oil, rattles, how far on last blinking led, 80mpg going downhill new threads pop up everyday. One can also add relevance to an old posting with new info. Unless the title is way off like "discovered today...."(about tire pressure) I add to postings.

 

I like the idea of including in search results, very prominently, "The last post in this thread is X months/years old." This would not prevent anybody from reviving an old thread, but would prevent inadvertent resurrections.